A Project of The Annenberg Public Policy Center
FactCheck.org is celebrating 15 years of holding politicians accountable.

Websites Distort Story of Former Federal Judge


Quick Take

Conservative websites falsely claim that former federal Judge Alex Kozinski “struck down” President Donald Trump’s original travel ban. He actually opposed its suspension. 


Full Story

Before federal Judge Alex Kozinski abruptly retired amid sexual harassment allegations late last year, he made news for a scathing dissent he wrote.

In his March 2017 dissenting opinion, Kozinski criticized three of his colleagues on the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for their decision to uphold a lower court’s temporary block on President Donald Trump’s original executive order instituting a travel ban on people from several predominantly Muslim countries.

Kozinski argued, for example, that the panel’s rationale that the executive order violated due process rights was misplaced because only a small fraction of the affected foreigners was entitled to due process. “This St. Bernard is being wagged by a flea on its tail,” he wrote.

But a handful of conservative websites this month posted a story that falsely describes Kozinski as a judge who “struck down” the travel ban, and presents the harassment allegations from last year as current news.

“9th Circuit Judge Who Struck Down Trump’s Muslim Travel Ban Busted In Sleazy Scandal,” reads the Dec. 5 headline on rightwing.news. The story earned thousands of shares on Facebook, and was also recently published on investmentwatchblog.com and therepublicanfighter.com.

The story goes on to include portions of two news articles — one from the Harvard Crimson and one from the Washington Post — about the allegations against Kozinski, who stepped down in December 2017.

But after that, the misleading story continues: “Now that’s sick, but then again, what else can we expect from a judge from the infamous 9th circuit court who is known for its radical far left agenda leanings.” The article refers twice to Kozinski as “liberal.”

In reality, Kozinski was widely known to be a conservative. He was nominated to the court by Republican President Ronald Reagan and was confirmed by the Senate in 1985, despite resistance from most Democrats.

In June, the Supreme Court upheld the Trump administration’s third iteration of the travel ban.

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org is one of several organizations working with Facebook to debunk misinformation shared on the social media network.

Update, Dec. 21: After we published our story, Right Wing News changed its headline to reflect that Kozinski had not “struck down” the travel ban. “Our headline was incorrect,” the website noted in an update. The website also removed all references to Kozinski being “liberal” and “far left” in its story.

Sources

Franklin, Ben A. “Senate Confirms Appellate Judge.” New York Times. 8 Nov 1985.

Gerstein, Josh. “9th Circuit judges in nasty feud over Trump travel ban.” Politico. 17 Mar 2017.

Kozinski, Alex.” Federal Judicial Center. Accessed 11 Dec 2018.

Ryan, Aidan F. “Harvard Law Student Group Cheers Changes to Federal Court’s Sexual Harassment Policies.” The Harvard Crimson. 30 Nov 2018.

State of Washington and State of Minnesota v. Donald J. Trump, et. al. “Amended Order.” U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. No. 17-35105. 17 Mar 2017.

Zapotosky, Matt. “Prominent appeals court Judge Alex Kozinski accused of sexual misconduct.” Washington Post. 8 Dec 2017.

Share the Facts
9
1
11
FactCheck.org rating logo FactCheck.org Rating:
Distorts the Facts
"9th Circuit Judge Who Struck Down Trump’s Muslim Travel Ban Busted In Sleazy Scandal"
Friday, December 7, 2018